videos

Bard violates Grice's maxims...again

A critical analysis of Google Bard failing to adhere to conversational principles by withholding relevant information about Gemini model availability in the EU. Bard violates Grice's Cooperative Principle by failing to proactively communicate that Gemini is unavailable in the EU due to regulatory reviews. The issue is not a hallucination but a failure of the maxim of quality: Bard does not provide necessary information unless explicitly asked. Users must already know the answer to their question before asking it, creating a paradoxical and unhelpful interaction pattern. Bard in Europe still runs on the older Lambda/PaLM model, not the newer Gemini model available in other regions. This violation of conversational principles is arguably worse than generating false information because it presupposes user knowledge.